Notes from the making of Cosmic Starship: what was tried, what was measured, and what was thrown away. The patch notes say what changed in each version. These say why.
Three features we built and took out againFleet Command, capturing enemy ships, and a reward formula that measured the wrong thing.
Four bugs worth rememberingA monster that could not die, a rival who won the wrong fight, and two more.
Making a campaign you can followPlayers were finishing the story without knowing what it was. What we changed.
How we know a change did not change the game93 scripted battles, hashed and compared on every release, and the damage steps whose order is tested.
Taking an engine out of a running gameThree stages of moving the clock, input, sound and 3D stage into a shared engine without changing a pixel.
Adding a civilization with ships we did not drawEleven CC0 spaceships converted to our scale and axes, and the bug no test could see.
Why the battles are flatA 3D picture on a flat battlefield: why Cosmic Starship is 2.5D and what that costs and buys.
What a crude bot says about 57 shipsEvery capital flown by the same bot in the same fight: what survived longest, and what the test cannot tell us.
Making a 3D Browser Game With three.js and No Build Step: How Cosmic Starship Is OrganizedPlain ES modules, vendored three.js r180, one-URL-per-module and two loading bugs we shipped and fixed.
We also write about real rockets in our spaceflight notes.
How the game is tested
Most of what you will read in these notes rests on one habit. Before a rule is kept, a test program flies the missions it touches, many times, with the rule on and off, and we look at who won and with how much hull left. It is a crude pilot. It strafes at gun range and fires at the nearest thing. But it is the same crude pilot every time, which makes it a fair ruler, and it has embarrassed more than one idea that sounded right in conversation.
It cannot tell us whether something is fun. For that there is only playing, and listening to people who play. Several of the changes described here began as one sentence from someone playing.