Why the battles are flat

Someone asked whether Cosmic Starship is a 2.5D game. The honest answer is a little awkward: it looks fully three-dimensional and plays on a flat sheet. Here is what that means and why we kept it that way.

Two worlds, one battle

Every ship is a real 3D model with textures and lights. The planets are spheres, the asteroids tumble, the camera can swing round, tilt and zoom, and there are chase, tactical and cinematic views. All of that is drawn by a 3D engine, three.js.

But a ship in the simulation has an x and a y, and no z. It cannot fly higher than another ship, it cannot dive under it, and a shot cannot miss by passing over the top. Distances, collisions and weapon ranges are measured on the plane. The third dimension exists only on the screen: the thickness of a hull, the tilt of a wing, the spread of an explosion. When we say a gun has a range of 480, we mean 480 on a flat map.

Why we did not go fully 3D

There are three reasons, and the first one is the strongest.

  • Repeatable battles. Our regression net depends on a battle playing out exactly the same way twice from the same seed. A flat world with fixed-step arithmetic is much easier to keep that way. The 93-battle fingerprint described in the testing note would be harder to keep with a third axis.
  • Crowds. A battle may field a few hundred ships. Finding who is near whom is cheap on a grid of squares and much more expensive in a volume. The simulator runs 150 fighters a side with room to spare.
  • Control. A mouse aims in two dimensions. In three, you need a way to tell the game how high you mean. Flight games solve it with a joystick and a lot of practice, and that is a different game from the one we wanted, where you command squads as much as you fly.

What 2.5D buys you

A flat simulation with 3D art lets us do things that look expensive. The camera is independent of the rules, so a cinematic shot or a chase camera costs nothing in the simulation. And a hit that passes through a ship’s gap, or a beam that crosses a line on the map, can be seen clearly from above, which makes the game readable at a glance: you know exactly where a beam will land.

What it costs

You give up some things honestly. There is no flying over a station or below a convoy, and no cover that depends on height. Everything that can hit you or block you is on the same sheet as you are.

What a bridge view would change

A first-person view from the bridge is possible, because the camera is separate from the rules. It would be the same flat battle seen from inside. A real 3D version, with ships that move up and down, would mean rewriting the simulation in three axes, changing ranges, collisions, formations and the AI, and starting again on the regression net. That is a different game, not an update, and we have not decided to make it.